Worst Medicare Advantage Plans

Compare affordable Medicare Plans


Russell Noga
by Russell Noga | Updated January 28th, 2024

The journey to securing quality healthcare coverage is a winding road filled with many decisions, especially when it comes to choosing a Medicare Advantage plan.

While these plans can offer a range of benefits, they can also present potential pitfalls that can significantly impact your healthcare coverage and financial well-being. In this post, we’ll guide you through these pitfalls – from high out-of-pocket expenses to limited provider networks and prior authorization hurdles, which are often associated with the worst Medicare Advantage plans.

But that’s not all. We’ll also help you decode those mystifying CMS star ratings, show you how to spot red flags and, most importantly, share strategies to escape potential Medicare Advantage nightmares.

So, let’s dive in and navigate this complex landscape together.


Key Takeaways

  • Medicare Advantage plans can pose significant challenges such as high out-of-pocket expenses, limited provider networks, and burdensome prior authorization requirements, which can impact the affordability and accessibility of medical care.
  • Low CMS Star Ratings for Medicare Advantage plans may signify inferior quality care, with customer service scores and health outcomes significantly influencing plan performance and enrolee experience.
  • Strategic options exist for individuals trapped in disadvantageous Medicare Advantage plans, such as switching to a different plan or returning to Original Medicare with Medigap to ensure better healthcare coverage tailored to individual needs.



Navigating the Pitfalls of Medicare Advantage Plans


Worst Medicare Advantage Plans Navigating the Pitfalls of Medicare Advantage Plans


Private insurance companies, approved by Medicare, offer Medicare Advantage plans as health insurance options. They offer an alternative to Original Medicare, providing Part A (Hospital Insurance) and Part B (Medical Insurance) coverage.

Some plans even offer additional benefits like:

  • vision
  • hearing
  • dental
  • wellness programs


Yet, a Medicare Advantage plan, like any journey, can present its unique set of challenges that, when overlooked, could morph into the worst Medicare Advantage nightmare. To avoid this, it’s essential to be well-informed about the Medicare Advantage program and its various aspects.

Some of the obstacles that could stand in your way when it comes to medical care include:

  • High out-of-pocket expenses, which can lead to unexpected bills and make medical care burdensome
  • Limited provider networks, which can restrict your ability to seek care from your preferred doctors and hospitals, especially if you require specialized treatment not offered within the network
  • Prior authorization requirements, which can result in delays in accessing comprehensive coverage and restrictions on a physician’s ability to provide prompt treatment.


These obstacles can make it challenging to receive the care you need.


The Burden of High Out-of-Pocket Expenses


Worst Medicare Advantage Plans The Burden of High Out-of-Pocket Expenses


One of the most significant pitfalls of Medicare Advantage plans is the potential for high out-of-pocket expenses. These are costs that you must pay yourself because they’re not covered by insurance.

In Medicare Advantage plans, these expenses can vary significantly and may include costs for services and items with similar cost-sharing arrangements as Original Medicare and Medicare supplement insurance. These can quickly add up, especially if you require frequent medical services or expensive treatments.

For instance, let’s consider the cost of cancer treatment. Medicare Advantage plans that require a 20% coinsurance for Part B medications can lead to substantial out-of-pocket expenses for cancer treatment.

Additionally, Medicare Advantage plans often entail per-day copays that surpass the Part A deductible for hospital admissions during inpatient visits. The issue is particularly common in Health Maintenance Organization (HMO) and Preferred Provider Organization (PPO) plans.

This poses a significant challenge for many individuals seeking healthcare coverage, including prescription drug coverage.

While HMO plans exclusively provide coverage for in-network services, PPO plans offer coverage for both in-network and out-of-network healthcare services, albeit typically with high out-of-pocket limits for out-of-network services. Understanding these costs and planning accordingly is fundamental to prevent unexpected and unaffordable medical bills.


Limited Provider Networks and Access Issues


Worst Medicare Advantage Plans Limited Provider Networks and Access Issues


When you join a Medicare Advantage Plan, you’re typically restricted to a network of doctors, hospitals, and other healthcare providers. This network is a group of healthcare providers who have agreed to treat Medicare Advantage members at a certain rate.

While this may sound beneficial, it can pose significant limitations, particularly when you need specialized treatment that is not offered within the network.

Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) and Preferred Provider Organizations (PPOs) are two common types of Medicare Advantage plans that use provider networks. HMOs exclusively cover in-network providers and often incorporate supplementary benefits and lower monthly expenses, but present more challenges for accessing specialist care.

On the other hand, PPOs permit access to both in-network and out-of-network providers, providing beneficiaries with more options. Assessing the network of each plan thoroughly to ensure it aligns with your medical requirements is vital.


Prior Authorization Hurdles


Worst Medicare Advantage Plans Prior Authorization Hurdles


Another pitfall to watch out for in Medicare Advantage plans is the hurdle of prior authorization requirements. These requirements mean that before you can receive certain services, your provider must first receive approval from the Medicare Advantage plan.

This can not only result in delays in accessing comprehensive coverage but also restrict a physician’s flexibility in providing prompt treatment.

Healthcare providers or suppliers are required to submit prior authorization requests along with the necessary medical documentation to the Medicare Advantage plan for approval.

The Kaiser Family Foundation’s report, based on a review of major Medicare Advantage carriers, revealed that more than 35 million prior authorization requests were submitted in 2021. The significant volume of these requests, along with the denial rates, may provide insights into the potential impact on patient care.


Discover 2024 Plans & Rates

Enter Zip Code


Deciphering the Low CMS Star Ratings


Worst Medicare Advantage Plans Deciphering the Low CMS Star Ratings


When you’re navigating the world of Medicare Advantage plans, one tool you might come across is the CMS Star Ratings. These ratings, which are released by Medicare, use a five-star scale to evaluate all Medicare Advantage plans.

They assess plans by considering factors such as customer service, member experience, and healthcare quality. But what does it mean if a plan has a low CMS star rating?

A low CMS star rating implies that the Medicare Advantage plan may not be delivering a satisfactory level of quality care in comparison to other plans.

The average star rating for Medicare Advantage plans, weighted by enrollment, decreased from 4.14 stars in 2023 to 4.04 stars in 2024 according to CMS, indicating a decline in the overall quality of the plans. This declining trend highlights the importance of carefully scrutinizing these ratings when selecting a plan.


Understanding the Impact of Customer Service Scores

Customer service scores play a significant role in the overall CMS star rating of a Medicare Advantage plan. These scores are determined through the Star Ratings system, which evaluates the plan’s quality of care, member experience, member complaints, and customer service.

But how do these customer service ratings affect the overall rating of a Medicare Advantage plan?

Customer service ratings have a considerable influence on the overall rating for Medicare Advantage plans as they provide an indication of plan performance in client interaction. These ratings also affect the earnings of the plans through the Star Ratings, which are utilized by Medicare consumers for comparing plan quality.

Low customer service scores can have adverse effects on Medicare Advantage plans, specifically impacting:

  • Member communication
  • Overall satisfaction
  • Plan’s reputation
  • Enrollee retention



Health Outcomes and Plan Performance

Health outcomes and plan performance are other factors that are considered in the CMS star rating of Medicare Advantage plans. These outcomes are assessed through the use of the Medicare Health Outcomes Survey (HOS) and the Star Ratings system.

These measures provide insight into the quality of care beneficiaries receive from their Medicare Advantage plan.

Studies have indicated that Medicare Advantage plans contribute to improved health outcomes for Medicare beneficiaries, as evidenced by reduced hospitalizations and decreased medical and prescription drug expenses.

However, it’s important to note that these outcomes can be influenced by a variety of factors, including the health status and healthcare use of the patient, supplemental coverage and premiums, Medicare Advantage plan benefits, risk-adjustment, upcoding of disease severity, bonus payments for quality performance, and social determinants of health.


Worst Medicare Advantage Plans


Identifying Red Flags in Medicare Advantage Plans

In navigating the Medicare Advantage landscape, it’s important to be vigilant for red flags. These are indicators of potential issues in Medicare Advantage Plans, and being aware of them can help you avoid falling into a Medicare Advantage nightmare.

Some of these red flags include:

  • Reimbursement problems
  • Unchecked creative marketing or misrepresentation
  • Inappropriate denials
  • Falling for low price points
  • Unsolicited requests for personal information or money


Being aware of these red flags can help protect you and ensure that you make informed decisions when it comes to Medicare Advantage Plans.

It’s also important to be aware of annual changes in Medicare Advantage plans. Typical yearly modifications in Medicare Advantage Plans encompass alterations to:

  • premiums
  • out-of-pocket costs
  • covered medications
  • provider and pharmacy networks


These adjustments can have a substantial impact on beneficiaries from one year to the next. Thoroughly assessing these changes and making informed decisions about your healthcare coverage is therefore important.


Warning Signs in Plan Details

One way to spot red flags is by closely examining the details of the Medicare Advantage plan. For instance, indicators of elevated expenses in Medicare Advantage plans encompass unforeseen costs during sickness and network constraints resulting in escalated out-of-pocket expenses.

It’s important to note specific service expenses, which may be higher in certain plans.

Inadequacies in a plan’s network can also be a warning sign. A larger network is generally indicative of more treatment options, while a plan with a limited network can pose challenges in accessing treatment.

Thoroughly assessing the network of each plan to ensure it aligns with your medical requirements is vital.


Evaluating Plan Changes Year Over Year

Evaluating changes in your Medicare Advantage plan from year to year is another way to spot potential issues. The annual changes in Medicare Advantage plans have the potential to influence health coverage through their impact on:

  • Enrollees’ premiums
  • Out-of-pocket costs
  • Access to medications
  • Provider and pharmacy networks


During the open enrollment period, it’s important to review these changes to make sure your coverage continues to align with your healthcare needs. Failing to assess these changes annually can lead to:

  • Reduced options compared to Medicare plus Medigap
  • Incomplete information hindering plan comparison and quality assessment
  • Alterations in coverage details that may not align with individual requirements
  • Possible difficulties for individuals residing in rural areas.

Worst Medicare Advantage Plans Strategies to Escape Medicare Advantage NightmaresStrategies to Escape Medicare Advantage Nightmares

If you find yourself in a Medicare Advantage nightmare, don’t despair. There are strategies you can employ to escape these pitfalls and secure better healthcare coverage.

Switching to a different Medicare Advantage plan is one effective strategy. Transitioning to a different plan can help you find better coverage that aligns with your healthcare needs.

Another strategy is to consider transitioning to Original Medicare and a Medigap plan. Offering greater flexibility, Original Medicare allows access to any medical provider that accepts Medicare.

While Original Medicare may not offer the same additional benefits as Medicare Advantage plans, it can be supplemented with a Medigap plan to assist in covering out-of-pocket expenses.


Switching to a Different Medicare Advantage Plan

Switching to a different Medicare Advantage plan can be a viable option if you’re unsatisfied with your current plan or if your healthcare needs have changed.

Before making a switch, it’s important to consider factors such as whether your current doctors accept the new plan, whether your medications are covered, and the out-of-pocket costs for services.

During the open enrollment period, you can transition to a different Medicare Advantage Plan by completing the enrollment process for the new plan. Once you’re enrolled in the new plan, you’ll be automatically disenrolled from your previous plan.

If you need help with this process, you can always reach out to 1-800-MEDICARE for assistance.


Considering Original Medicare and Medigap

If Medicare Advantage plans are not meeting your healthcare needs, another option is to consider transitioning to Original Medicare and a Medigap plan. Original Medicare, which is managed by the federal government, provides Part A (Hospital Insurance) and Part B (Medical Insurance) coverage, also known as Medicare coverage.

Medigap is a supplemental insurance policy sold by private companies to help cover some of the healthcare costs not covered by Original Medicare, such as co-payments, coinsurance, and deductibles.

However, it’s important to note that not everyone is eligible to receive a Medigap plan, and some seniors may face challenges affording this supplemental coverage.


Worst Medicare Advantage Plans How to Secure Better Healthcare CoverageHow to Secure Better Healthcare Coverage

After escaping a Medicare Advantage nightmare, your next step is to secure better healthcare coverage, including exploring Medicaid services. You can achieve this by assessing your healthcare needs, comparing plan features and benefits, and seeking assistance from licensed insurance agents.

Assessing your healthcare needs involves considering factors such as your health status, age, cognitive ability, and the resources and capacity available.

Comparing plan features and benefits involves looking at the costs, coverage, benefits, and provider networks of different Medicare Advantage plans.

If you need assistance navigating the complex landscape of Medicare Advantage plans, licensed insurance agents can provide personalized guidance and support.


Assessing Your Healthcare Needs

Understanding your healthcare needs is the first step to finding a Medicare Advantage plan that provides the right coverage and benefits.

You’ll need to take into account factors such as:

  • your health status
  • age
  • cognitive ability
  • the resources and capacity available


For instance, older adults may encounter increased out-of-pocket medical expenses, while those with chronic illnesses might require additional support services. You must assess your healthcare needs and find a plan that best suits those needs.


Comparing Plan Features and Benefits

Once you have a clear understanding of your healthcare needs, the next step is to compare the features and benefits of different Medicare Advantage plans. This involves reviewing and comparing:

  • The costs of different plans
  • The coverage provided by each plan
  • The benefits offered by each plan
  • The provider networks associated with each plan


By comparing these factors, you can make an informed decision about which Medicare Advantage plan is the best Medicare Advantage plan for you among most Medicare Advantage plans.

It’s also important to consider added benefits like fitness programs, dental, and vision care. It is important to balance your budget with your healthcare needs in order to find an affordable coverage plan.

This will ensure that you have financial stability while also meeting your medical requirements. For comparing plans, online tools such as the eHealth Medicare comparison tool or the Medicare Plan Finder tool on Medicare.gov can be useful.


Seeking Assistance from Licensed Insurance Agents

Choosing a Medicare Advantage plan can be a complex process, but you don’t have to navigate it alone. Licensed insurance agents offer impartial assistance and support at no cost to help individuals navigate the intricate landscape of Medicare Advantage plans.

These agents, also known as brokers, possess a comprehensive understanding of the Medicare system. They can guide you on enrolling in Medicare plans, evaluate the benefits and limitations of the plans, and provide information to help you choose the right coverage.


Choosing a Medicare Advantage plan is a crucial decision that can significantly impact your healthcare coverage and financial well-being.

But by understanding the potential pitfalls, deciphering the CMS star ratings, identifying red flags, and employing strategies to escape Medicare Advantage nightmares, you can secure better healthcare coverage that meets your individual needs.

Remember, the journey to securing quality healthcare coverage may be winding, but with the right information and guidance, you can navigate it successfully.



Compare 2024 Plans & Rates

Enter Zip Code






Frequently Asked Questions


  Who has the highest star rated Medicare Advantage plans?

Humana Insurance Company has the highest star-rated Medicare Advantage plans.


  Why are people leaving Medicare Advantage plans?

Many people are leaving Medicare Advantage plans due to excessive prior authorization denial rates, slow payments from insurers, and allegations of billing fraud from the federal government, leading to high denial rates. These issues have prompted individuals to seek other healthcare options.


  What is the best Medicare Advantage plan for 2024?

The best Medicare Advantage plan for 2024 is offered by Humana, which is known for its high quality ratings, good customer satisfaction, widespread availability, and numerous $0-per-month plans. Customers are reporting better healthcare quality compared to AARP/UHC.


  What is the disadvantage of UnitedHealthcare?

The main disadvantage of UnitedHealthcare is its average customer satisfaction ratings, with some markets rating the company as about average according to the latest J.D. Power survey. This means it may not be as strong as some other top-ranking companies, like Humana.


  How do CMS star ratings evaluate Medicare Advantage plans?

CMS star ratings evaluate Medicare Advantage plans using a five-star scale, taking into account customer service, member experience, and healthcare quality.


Find the Right Medicare Plan for You

Finding the right Medicare Plan 2024 doesn’t have to be confusing. Whether it’s a Medigap plan, or you want to know more about Advantage, we can help.

Call us today at 1-888-891-0229 and one of our knowledgeable, licensed insurance agents will be happy to assist you!


Medicare Supplement Plan G Rates