The Average Cost of Supplemental Insurance for Medicare in 2024

Compare affordable Medicare Plans

Russell Noga
by Russell Noga | Updated September 28th, 2023

What is the Average Cost of Medicare Supplement Insurance

Best medicare supplement plans When it comes to understanding and finding out the various costs associated with different Medigap plans and companies, it can be quite a battle.

However, with the right information and people to guide you at your fingertips, you can make informed decisions about Medicare and which plan best suits your needs and budget.

This article will provide you with a comprehensive understanding of the average cost of Supplemental Insurance for Medicare, breaking down the various factors that influence them, and offering valuable tips for comparing and choosing the right plan for you.


Short Summary

  • Medicare Supplement Insurance costs range from as low as $50 to over $500 per month
  • Factors such as Plan letter, location, age, gender, and tobacco use can influence the cost of plans.
  • At we help you evaluate plans to get the right coverage to fit your needs

Overview of Medicare Supplement Insurance Costs

Medicare Supplement Insurance, also known as Medigap, is designed to fill the gaps in Original Medicare coverage by covering certain copays, coinsurance, and deductibles.

The cost of Medicare Supplement plans varies widely, with monthly premiums ranging from as low as $50 to over $500 depending on various factors. These factors include:


  • The specific Medigap plan chosen
  • The insurance company offering the plan
  • Personal factors such as age, gender, tobacco use, zip code, if any discounts apply



How much is supplemental health insurance



It’s essential to understand that although the benefits offered by each standardized Medigap plan are the same across insurance companies, the premiums charged can vary significantly between companies.

Furthermore, without the protection of a Medigap plan, you could potentially face high coinsurance and hospital costs due to deductibles, coinsurance, or copayments not covered by Original Medicare.

To help you navigate these costs and make an informed decision, this blog post will:


  • Break down the average cost of Medicare Supplement Insurance
  • Discuss the factors influencing these costs
  • Provide valuable tips for comparing and choosing the right plan for you.



View Medigap Rates for 2024

Enter Zip Code



Breaking Down Medigap Plan Costs

The cost of each Medigap policy type may vary significantly, with Medigap premiums for plans offering less coverage generally being lower, and Medicare supplemental insurance plans with more coverage tend to have higher premiums.

For example, the price ranges for Medigap Plans A, B, D, G, High-deductible Plans G, K, L, M, and N for a 65-year-old nonsmoker in North Carolina are as follows:


  • Plan A: $85-$416
  • Plan B: $113-$303
  • Plan D: $106-$340
  • Plan G: $96-$341
  • High-deductible Plan G: $30-$67
  • Plan K: $47-$121
  • Plan L: $59-$250
  • Plan M: $72-$274
  • Plan N: $72-$310


It is important to compare the average cost of each standardized type of Medicare Supplement Insurance plan to ascertain what factors influence these expenses and compare plans in your area. This will help you maximize your Medicare benefits and choose the most suitable plan for your needs.

Keep in mind that while the premiums for specific Medigap plans can vary, the coverage offered by each standardized plan is the same across insurance companies. This means that the primary difference you need to consider when comparing plans is the cost, as well as any additional benefits or discounts offered by the insurance company.



book appointment


Factors Influencing Medicare Supplement Insurance Costs

The principal elements that influence the cost of Medicare Supplement Insurance plans are:


  • Location
  • Age
  • Gender
  • Tobacco use


In the following subsections, we will delve deeper into each of these factors and how they impact the cost of Medigap plans.

Location is a major factor in determining the cost of a Medigap plan. Rates vary.


Plan Benefits and Coverage

What are the top 5 medicare supplement plans? When it comes to the cost of Medigap plans, the benefits and coverage levels play a significant role. Generally, more comprehensive plans will come with higher costs.

For example, a plan that covers a significant portion of your out-of-pocket costs may have a higher premium than a plan with less coverage.

One factor that can impact the cost of a Medigap plan is medical underwriting. Underwriting is the procedure by which an insurance provider evaluates one’s current health and health history to decide the costs for a Medigap plan.

The insurance company may refuse coverage if they decide your health history is too high risk. This can be very disheartening for those in need of coverage.

However, it’s important to note that there are protections in place to ensure access to Medigap coverage for those who need it. For example, during the 6-Month Medigap Open Enrollment Period or when you have a guaranteed issue right, insurance companies are prohibited from factoring your health or medical history into the price or approval of your policy.


Insurance Company Variability

As previously mentioned, the cost of Medicare Supplement Insurance plans is determined by private insurance companies, and the same plans can be offered at varying prices by different companies.

This variability in pricing is due to the unique methods used by each company to calculate the cost of Medigap plans based on factors such as:


  • Zip Code
  • Age
  • Gender
  • Tobacco use
  • Household and other discounts (if applicable)


When selecting a carrier for a Medicare Supplement plan, it’s important to consider factors such as the financial rating of the company (A or better), their rate increase history, and their experience in the market (a minimum of five years).

By taking these factors into account, you can ensure that you are choosing a reliable and trustworthy provider for your Medigap coverage.

It’s also worth noting that while the benefits of Medigap plans are identical across carriers, the premium you pay may vary. This means that it’s crucial to shop around and compare plans from different companies to find the best value and coverage for your needs.


Age-Related Pricing Models

Age is another factor that can significantly impact the cost of Medicare Supplement Insurance plans. Insurance companies use various age-related pricing models, including community-rated, issue-age-rated, and attained-age-rated.

In a community-rated or ‘no age-related’ Medigap policy, all individuals with the policy are subject to the same rate, regardless of age. With issue-age-rated pricing, the cost of the policy is contingent upon the age at which it is initially purchased, with younger individuals typically having lower monthly premiums.

Finally, in an attained-age-rated policy, the cost is associated with the current age of the policyholder and increases annually as they age.

Understanding these age-related pricing models can help you make informed decisions about which Medigap plan is best suited for your needs and budget. It’s also important to consider that other factors, such as location, gender, and tobacco use, may also impact your Medigap plan costs.

Enrollment Timing and Guaranteed Issue Rights

Enrollment timing and guaranteed issue rights play a crucial role in determining Medigap plan costs and coverage availability.

The Medigap Open Enrollment Period is a six-month period commencing when an individual attains the age of 65 and is enrolled in Medicare Part B. During this period, insurance companies are prohibited from factoring the individual’s health or medical history into the price, ensuring that everyone has access to Medigap coverage at a fair cost.

Top 10 medicare supplement insurance companies

Medigap guaranteed issue right allows you to enroll in a Medigap plan without the need for medical underwriting.

This is an opportunity that should not be overlooked. This means that regardless of your health status or medical history, you will be able to secure coverage at a fair price. However, it’s important to note that these rights may not be available indefinitely, so it’s crucial to take advantage of them when they are available.

Enrolling in a Medicare Supplement plan at age 65, as opposed to waiting, can also help you secure lower premiums and better coverage options. If you wait until a later age to enroll, your Medicare Supplement cost may be higher, and you may have fewer coverage options available to you.

By enrolling during the Open Enrollment Period or during a guaranteed issue right, you can protect yourself from potentially higher Medicare Supplement Insurance costs due to your health.


Discounts and Savings Opportunities

Worst medicare supplement companies While the cost of Medicare Supplement Insurance plans can vary widely, there are various discounts and savings opportunities available to help you manage these expenses.

For example, some carriers offer household discounts, which may result in a 5-15% reduction in the cost of policies.

Additionally, tobacco users may incur up to 10% higher monthly premiums, so quitting smoking can lead to significant savings on your Medigap coverage.

Other examples of Medigap discounts include online application discounts, automatic or prepayment discounts, and multi-policy discounts. Some companies offer discounts for paying your premiums on an annual basis.

By taking advantage of these discounts and savings opportunities, you can help minimize the financial burden of your Medicare Supplement Insurance coverage.

It’s important to discuss these potential discounts with us, as we can help you identify the best options and savings opportunities for your specific needs and circumstances.

We’ll save you time when it comes to comparing the average cost of Medicare Supplement Insurance plans in your area, and also help you find a plan that offers the best value and coverage for you.

Evaluating the Value of Medicare Supplement Insurance Plans

When assessing the worth of Medicare Supplement Insurance plans, it’s essential to consider several key factors, including coverage, predictability of healthcare spending, and budgeting for care.

A Medigap plan that offers comprehensive coverage can help minimize your out-of-pocket costs, ensuring that you have access to the healthcare you need without breaking the bank.

Furthermore, a Medigap plan with predictable monthly premiums can help you more accurately budget for your healthcare expenses, providing peace of mind and financial stability. This can be especially important for those on a fixed income, such as retirees or individuals with disabilities.

Ultimately, the value of a Medicare Supplement Insurance plan is determined by your unique needs, circumstances, and priorities. By carefully considering these factors and working with a licensed insurance agent, you can find the plan that offers the best combination of cost, coverage, and peace of mind for your specific situation.


Comparing and Choosing a Medicare Supplement Insurance Plan

When it comes to comparing and choosing a Medicare Supplement Insurance plan, there are several factors you should take into account, including the cost, coverage, and reputation of the provider.



Medigap cost comparison chart


To help with this process, you can work with one of our licensed insurance agents who can facilitate the comparison of the average cost of Medicare Supplement Insurance plans in your vicinity and identify a plan that is suitable for you.

As you evaluate and compare Medigap plan quotes, it’s crucial to examine them thoroughly, as pricing can sometimes be counterintuitive. For instance, a Medigap Plan G offering comprehensive coverage may be priced lower than Plan A, which provides only basic coverage. This highlights the importance of carefully assessing each plan and considering factors beyond just the monthly premium.

By taking the time to thoroughly research, compare, and evaluate your options, you can make an informed decision and choose a Medicare Supplement Insurance plan or a Medicare Advantage Plan that offers the best value, coverage, and peace of mind for your unique needs.

We make it easy!


In conclusion, understanding the costs associated with Medicare Supplement Insurance plans is crucial for making informed decisions about your healthcare coverage.

By considering factors such as plan benefits, insurance company variability, age-related pricing models, enrollment timing, and available discounts, you can identify the plan that offers the best value and coverage for your unique needs.

Navigating the world of Medicare Supplement Insurance can be challenging, but with the right information and resources at your fingertips, you can confidently choose the plan that best suits your needs and budget, ensuring that you have access to the healthcare you need without breaking the bank.



Get Quotes in Two Steps!

Enter Zip Code


Frequently Asked Questions

What is the typical cost of a Medicare Supplement plan?

The typical cost of a Medicare Supplement plan is around $150 per month, with premiums ranging from $50 to $450.

Please note that rates may vary significantly by plan. Use our FREE online quote engine to check the rates in your area, or call us today at 1-888-891-0229.


Why is Medicare Supplement so expensive?

Medicare Supplement plans are relatively inexpensive considering the coverage they provide. For example, a Medicare Plan G will pay 100% of the gaps and expenses that Medicare Part A and Medicare Part B do not, except for the annual Medicare Part B deductible each year. That deductible is only $226 in 2023, so you can see just how much coverage you are getting, particularly for major health conditions.

And with no network to adhere to, Medigap plans offer a peace of mind for Medicare beneficiaries that can be found with no other type of plan, particularly Medicare Advantage plans.

What is the most popular Medicare Supplement plan?

Plan F and Plan G are the most popular Medicare Supplement plans due to their outstanding coverage.


Is there a Medicare Supplement that covers everything?

No single Medicare Supplement plan covers everything, but Medicare Plan F is the most comprehensive one, providing 100% coverage of Medicare-covered medical expenses after Original Medicare pays its portion. Medicare Plan G is next, with 100% coverage after a small deductible.


What factors influence the cost of Medicare Supplement Insurance plans?

The cost of Medicare Supplement Insurance plans is largely determined by location, age, gender, and tobacco use.

Find the Right Medicare Plan for You



Finding the right Medicare Plan for 2024 doesn’t have to be confusing. Whether it’s a Medigap plan, or you want to know more about the average cost of Medicare Supplement Insurance, we can help.

Call us today at 1-888-891-0229 and one of our knowledgeable, licensed insurance agents will be happy to assist you!


Medicare Supplement Plan G Rates