Aetna vs Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement Plans: A 2027 Side-by-Side From State Filings

Compare affordable Medicare Plans

Comparing Aetna vs Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement plans, Mutual of Omaha usually wins at age 65: in Maryland’s 2027 rate guide its Plan G is $278 a month for a man versus $300 at Aetna’s best rate class, and its 12% household discount beats Aetna’s 7%. Aetna’s list price catches up with age and drops below Mutual of Omaha’s from age 80 in that same guide.

Head-to-head quote

Price Aetna and Mutual of Omaha for Your Own ZIP Code

State guides show the pattern. A quote shows which company wins for you.

Compare Rates

Rates and plan availability vary by state, age and insurance company.

Both companies sell the same standardized letters, so a Plan G from either one pays identical claims. The contest is price, discounts, rate trend and service. Every figure below comes from a state insurance department filing, AM Best, or a dated consumer review, with the source named, so you can check it yourself.

The verdict up front

Mutual of Omaha tends to be cheaper for new 65-year-old buyers, especially with its 12% household discount, and has the higher AM Best rating; Aetna has shown slower recent rate increases and lower list prices at older ages in Maryland.

Company Snapshot: Aetna and Mutual of Omaha Compared

FactorMutual of OmahaAetna
AM Best ratingA+ (Superior), affirmed April 2026A (Excellent), affirmed June 2026
OwnershipMutual holding company since April 1, 2026Subsidiary of CVS Health since 2018
Household discount, Maryland 2027 filing12%7%
Where it sells MedigapD.C. and every state except MassachusettsD.C. and every state except Massachusetts and Washington
Complaints versus expected, NAIC 2023 to 2025About 58% fewerAbout 18% more
Average yearly price increase, last three yearsAbout 12.7%About 8.4%
Share of premium paid out in benefits85.4%92.3%
Fitness extraMutually Well; gym access $29.99 a monthSilverSneakers terms on its Medigap shopping page; confirm by state

Sources: AM Best releases (April 2 and June 5, 2026); Maryland Insurance Administration 2027 rate guide; NerdWallet company reviews dated July 29 and August 1, 2026, citing NAIC data and Medicare.gov prices; Mutual of Omaha and Aetna websites.

The table cuts both ways. Mutual of Omaha leads on rating, discount and complaints. Aetna has raised prices more slowly in recent years and paid a larger share of each premium dollar back as claims. You can read each company alone in our Aetna Medicare Supplement and Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement reviews.

Aetna vs Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement plans scorecard: AM Best ratings, Maryland household discounts and Plan G at 65

Maryland 2027: Both Companies’ Rates at Age 65

Maryland is one of the few states whose guide prints both companies at five ages, with rates effective January 1, 2027. Mutual of Omaha prices by tobacco use; Aetna prices by preferred and standard health classes.

Plan, age 65Mutual of Omaha, non-tobaccoAetna, preferredAetna, standard
Plan G, man$278$300$334
Plan G, woman$242$261$290
Plan N, man$197$194$215
Plan N, woman$171$169$187
High-deductible G, man$61$54$60

Source: Maryland Insurance Administration Medicare Supplement rate guide, effective January 1, 2027. Monthly premiums before household discounts.

Plan N and high-deductible G flip the result

Aetna’s preferred rate is a few dollars lower for Plan N and $7 lower for high-deductible G. Mutual of Omaha’s edge is in Plan G, the most popular letter for new enrollees.

Now add the discounts. A 65-year-old man who qualifies for each company’s household discount would pay about $244.64 for Mutual of Omaha Plan G and $279.00 for Aetna at preferred rates, a gap of $34.36 a month, or about $412 a year.

The Age-80 Crossover

Both companies use attained-age pricing in Maryland, but their premiums climb at different speeds. Aetna starts higher and rises more slowly, so its Plan G list price passes below Mutual of Omaha’s around age 80.

Man, Plan GMutual of OmahaAetna preferredAfter household discounts (MoO / Aetna)
Age 65$278$300$244.64 / $279.00
Age 70$308$319$271.04 / $296.67
Age 75$369$375$324.72 / $348.75
Age 80$447$441$393.36 / $410.13
Age 85$535$515$470.80 / $478.95

Our analysis of the Maryland 2027 rate guide: list premiums, then 12% off Mutual of Omaha and 7% off Aetna.

What this means

Without a household discount, Aetna is the cheaper Plan G list price from age 80 in Maryland. With both discounts applied, Mutual of Omaha stays lower at every age shown, though the gap narrows to about $8 a month at 85.

Russell Noga, licensed insurance agent

Rule of thumb

A household discount is filed per company and per state, and it can end if the qualifying household changes. Comparing two insurers on list price alone can point to the wrong one: in Maryland, a 5-point difference in household discounts outweighs a list price that is a few dollars lower.

Russell Noga, Licensed Insurance Agent

Aetna vs Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement Plan G list premiums for a man in Maryland 2027 at ages 65 and 85

New Jersey and Three Cities: Does the Pattern Hold?

New Jersey’s September 2026 chart for a 65-year-old man at preferred rates shows a wider gap. Mutual of Omaha files there through United World Life.

New Jersey, man 65, monthly
$228.02
Mutual of Omaha Plan G
$299.88
Aetna Plan G
$159.23
Mutual of Omaha Plan N
$200.84
Aetna Plan N
City, woman 65Plan G: MoO / AetnaPlan N: MoO / Aetna
Los Angeles$231 / $240$149 / $164
Atlanta$256 / $274$169 / $141
Dallas$190 / $211$133 / $104

Source: NerdWallet reviews of each company (July and August 2026) using Medicare.gov prices for a 65-year-old female nonsmoker.

Mutual of Omaha’s Plan G is lower in all three cities, while Aetna’s Plan N is lower in Atlanta and Dallas. If you lean toward Plan N, do not assume the Plan G winner also wins on N. For more on pricing, see our Mutual of Omaha Plan G rates and Aetna Plan G pages.

Aetna and Mutual of Omaha Quotes

Call a Licensed Agent Now

A licensed agent can price both companies, plus other insurers, for your age and ZIP code.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No obligation to enroll

Underwriting and Rate Classes Work Differently

Mutual of Omaha
Separates tobacco and non-tobacco rates. Its Maryland tobacco Plan G for a man at 65 is $320, about 15% above the non-tobacco rate.
Aetna
Uses preferred and standard classes. A man at 65 classed standard pays $334 for Plan G, about 11% above preferred.
The protected windows
Maryland bars both higher classes for applications made during open enrollment, a guaranteed issue period or the 30-day birthday window.

Outside those windows, health answers can place you in a costlier class or lead to a decline at either company. That is why your first six months with Part B, starting the month you are 65 or older and enrolled, is the cheapest time to choose between them.

Which Company Fits Which Buyer

Lean Mutual of Omaha if
✔

You are 65 to 79 and want Plan G
✔

You live with a spouse or another adult and qualify for the 12% discount
✔

A top financial strength rating and low complaint count matter to you
Lean Aetna if
✕

You want Plan N or high-deductible G and Aetna’s quote is lower
✕

You are buying at 80 or older without a household discount
✕

A slower recent rate trend weighs more for you than today’s price

Benefits under the 2027 Medicare figures are identical either way: Plan G leaves the $292 Part B deductible, high-deductible G requires $3,050 before paying, and neither includes drug coverage. Browse other carriers in our Medicare Supplement section, the 2027 Medicare Supplement plans guide, or the Medisupps.com home page.

Beyond two companies

Check Whether a Third Insurer Beats Both

The lowest Plan G in many states comes from neither company. See the full field.

See All Rates

Rates and plan availability vary by state, age and insurance company.

Aetna or Mutual of Omaha: Frequently Asked Questions

➤ Is Aetna or Mutual of Omaha cheaper for Medicare Supplement Plan G?

In Maryland’s 2027 guide, Mutual of Omaha is cheaper for a 65-year-old ($278 versus $300 a month for a man). New Jersey’s chart and Medicare.gov checks in three cities show the same direction at 65. At 80 and older, Aetna’s Maryland list price is lower.

➤ Which company has the better financial rating?

Mutual of Omaha holds an A+ (Superior) Financial Strength Rating from AM Best, affirmed in April 2026. Aetna’s Medigap insurers share an A (Excellent) rating, affirmed in June 2026. Both are strong ratings.

➤ How do the household discounts compare?

Maryland’s 2027 filings list 12% for Mutual of Omaha and 7% for Aetna for applicants who qualify. Discount rules and amounts differ by state.

➤ Does either company sell Medigap in Massachusetts?

No. Neither sells there, and Aetna also does not sell Medigap in Washington state, according to 2026 company reviews.

➤ Do Aetna and Mutual of Omaha plans cover the same things?

Yes. Medigap letters are standardized by federal law, so Plan G or Plan N pays the same benefits from either insurer. Only the price, discounts, extras and service differ.

➤ Can I switch from Aetna to Mutual of Omaha later?

Yes, but outside your open enrollment or a guaranteed issue right, the new company can ask health questions. Maryland residents also have a 30-day window after each birthday to move to a plan with equal or lesser benefits.

Side-by-Side Medigap Rates

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G and Plan N premiums from several companies in one call.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No obligation to enroll

Medisupps.com is operated by ZRN Health & Financial Services, LLC, a licensed insurance agency based in Austin, Texas. We are not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program. Premiums are examples only; your rate depends on your age, ZIP code, tobacco use and the insurance company.