Cigna Medicare Supplement Plans 2027: How HealthSpring Rates Stack Up

Compare affordable Medicare Plans

Cigna Medicare Supplement plans for 2027 are sold under the HealthSpring name by Health Care Service Corporation, and in state rate guides their pattern is consistent: Plan N is priced among the lowest on the market, while Plan G sits in the middle or upper half. In Maryland’s January 2027 guide, HealthSpring’s Plan N for a 65-year-old man is tied for seventh-lowest of 23 listings, but its Plan G ranks 18th of 24.

Former Cigna plans, 2027 prices

Check HealthSpring Against Other Companies in Your ZIP Code

Its Plan N may be the low price where you live, or it may not. A side-by-side quote shows you.

Compare Rates

Rates and plan availability vary by state, age and insurance company.

That gap between the two plans is the most useful thing to know before you request a quote, and it holds in New Jersey too. This page lines HealthSpring up against the competition in both states, works through how its household discount compares, and summarizes what AM Best said about the company’s finances in January 2026. If you want the story of the sale and the renaming itself, our main Cigna Medicare Supplement plans page covers it.

What the guides show

For 2027, the former Cigna Medigap plans, now HealthSpring, are most competitive on Plan N, near the bottom of the price range in Maryland and New Jersey, while HealthSpring’s Plan G is mid-priced and its high-deductible Plan G was the most expensive listed in New Jersey’s September 2026 chart.

Whose Name Is on a Cigna Medigap Policy in 2027

Health Care Service Corporation, the parent of Blue Cross and Blue Shield plans in several states, bought Cigna’s Medicare business in a deal that closed in March 2025. State rate guides now list the main Medigap issuer as HealthSpring National Health Insurance Company. Benefits did not change, since every plan letter is standardized by federal law; what you are comparing is price, discounts and the company’s finances.

HealthSpring Medigap at a glance
A
AM Best rating, affirmed January 2026
March 2025
HCSC purchase closed
11
Companies in the rated group
Plan N
Its most competitive plan letter

Where HealthSpring Ranks in Maryland’s 2027 Guide

The Maryland Insurance Administration publishes monthly premiums for every Medigap insurer in the state. Here is HealthSpring next to four large competitors for a 65-year-old man in the preferred or non-tobacco class, effective January 1, 2027.

CompanyPlan GPlan N
HealthSpring$288$179
Aetna$300$194
Mutual of Omaha$278$197
Humana$246$178
State Farm$224$173

Source: Maryland Insurance Administration, Monthly Premiums for Medicare Supplement Insurance Policies, as of January 1, 2027, male, age 65. Sample figures for one state.

HealthSpring has the widest gap between its own Plan G and Plan N of the five. Its Plan N is within a dollar of Humana’s and below Aetna’s and Mutual of Omaha’s, while its Plan G costs $42 a month more than Humana’s. Across all insurers in the guide, by our count, HealthSpring’s Plan N is tied for seventh-lowest of 23, and its Plan G is 18th of 24.

Cigna Medicare Supplement plans 2027: monthly price gap between Plan G and Plan N in Maryland, HealthSpring $109, Aetna $106, Mutual of Omaha $81, Humana $68, State Farm $51

New Jersey Shows the Same Pattern

New Jersey’s Division of Aging Services publishes a one-page chart of monthly premiums at age 65. The September 2026 edition, the latest before 2027 renewals, tells a similar story for HealthSpring.

Plan N: $122.56
Second-lowest of 21 Plan N listings, behind only one company at $119.90.
Plan G: $214.14
Ninth-lowest of 19 Plan G listings, about $50 a month above the lowest.
High-deductible G: $92.08
The highest of 13 high-deductible Plan G listings; the lowest was $50.83.

Two states are not the whole country, but when the same pricing shape shows up in both, it is a fair guide to where HealthSpring is likely to be worth a look: Plan N first, Plan G only after checking other companies, and high-deductible G probably elsewhere.

HealthSpring Rate Check

Call a Licensed Agent Now

A licensed agent can compare HealthSpring with other Medigap companies at no cost.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No obligation to enroll

Household Discounts: Plan N Prices After the Discount

Discounts change the order. Maryland’s guide lists a 6% HealthSpring household discount when the applicant lives with another adult, such as a spouse or domestic partner, plus an additional 14% when more than one household member enrolls in an affiliate policy. Ask the company exactly how the two discounts combine before you count on both. Competitors file their own terms.

Plan N, male 65, Maryland 2027BaseHousehold discountAfter discount
Humana$17812%$156.64
HealthSpring$1796%$168.26
Mutual of Omaha$19712%$173.36
Aetna$1947%$180.42

Our math from the Maryland Insurance Administration guide, January 1, 2027. HealthSpring’s additional 14% affiliate discount is not applied. Discount rules and eligibility differ by company.

With only its 6% discount, HealthSpring falls behind Humana for a two-person household. If both members qualify for the extra affiliate discount, HealthSpring could move back ahead, which is why the exact discount wording matters.

Russell Noga, licensed insurance agent

Discount detail

A household discount is tied to the current living situation. If the other adult in the home moves out or dies, the discount can end at the next renewal and the remaining policy’s premium rises, so a quote that includes a discount is worth comparing with and without it.

Russell Noga, Licensed Insurance Agent

What AM Best Said in January 2026

On January 15, 2026, AM Best affirmed the A (Excellent) financial strength rating and a long-term issuer credit rating of a for 11 HCSC Medicare and supplemental companies, including HealthSpring National Health Insurance Company, Loyal American Life and American Retirement Life, with a stable outlook.

Strengths AM Best cited
✔

Balance sheet strength assessed as very strong
✔

Capital added during 2025, with more committed by the parent
✔

Support from HCSC, which is expected to provide funds if needed
Concerns AM Best noted
✕

Operating performance assessed as marginal
✕

Higher-than-expected medical cost trends
✕

Medicare reimbursement changes, with pressure expected to continue into 2026

The review covers the group’s whole Medicare business, which includes Medicare Advantage and Part D as well as Medigap. For a Medigap buyer, cost pressure of this kind can show up in future rate filings, so ask for HealthSpring’s recent rate increases in your state.

Cigna Medicare Supplement plans 2027 under HealthSpring: where its prices compete and where they lag in Maryland and New Jersey rate guides

Before You Buy a HealthSpring Medigap Plan

1
Quote Plan N first. It is where HealthSpring has been most competitive in both state guides.
2
Price Plan G across companies. HealthSpring’s Plan G was mid-priced or higher, so a competitor may save you several hundred dollars a year.
3
Skip its high-deductible G unless your state differs. In New Jersey it carried the highest high-deductible Plan G premium listed.
4
Get the discount terms in writing. Confirm whether the 6% and the 14% affiliate discounts both apply to you.

For Plan N details, see Cigna Medicare Supplement Plan N. To compare every insurer, browse Medicare Supplement plans, the Medicare Supplement plans by year section, the 2027 Medicare Supplement plans guide, or the Medisupps.com home page.

Free quote comparison

See Whether HealthSpring Plan N or Another Plan G Costs Less

Compare several Medigap insurers for the plan letter you want.

Get My Quotes

Rates and plan availability vary by state, age and insurance company.

Cigna and HealthSpring Medigap Rates: Common Questions

➤ Is Cigna Medicare Supplement cheaper than Humana in 2027?

It depends on the plan. In Maryland’s January 2027 guide, HealthSpring’s Plan N for a 65-year-old man was $179 a month against Humana’s $178, but its Plan G was $288 against Humana’s $246.

➤ Where does HealthSpring’s Plan N rank on price?

Near the bottom of the range in the two guides we checked: tied for seventh-lowest of 23 listings in Maryland for 2027, and second-lowest of 21 in New Jersey’s September 2026 chart.

➤ Does HealthSpring sell high-deductible Plan G?

In some states. New Jersey’s September 2026 chart lists it at $92.08 a month for a 65-year-old man, the highest of 13 companies listed for that plan.

➤ Will HCSC’s ownership change my Cigna Medigap rates?

Rates are filed and approved state by state, just as before the sale. Ownership does not change your benefits, but future increases depend on claims and on the company’s financial results.

➤ How does HealthSpring’s household discount work in Maryland?

The guide lists 6% when the applicant lives with another adult such as a spouse or domestic partner, plus an additional 14% when more than one household member enrolls in an affiliate policy.

➤ What did AM Best say about HealthSpring’s finances?

In January 2026 it affirmed an A (Excellent) rating with a stable outlook, calling the balance sheet very strong and operating performance marginal because of rising medical costs.

Medigap Quote Comparison

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare former Cigna plans with other top insurers in one call.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No obligation to enroll

Medisupps.com is operated by ZRN Health & Financial Services, LLC, a licensed insurance agency based in Austin, Texas. We are not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program. Premiums are examples only; your rate depends on your age, ZIP code, tobacco use and the insurance company.