Best Medicare Supplement Plans NYC

Compare affordable Medicare Plans

Russell Noga
by Russell Noga | Updated March 4th, 2024

Are you trying to find the best Medicare Supplement Plans NYC to complement your Original Medicare coverage? This article cuts through the complexity to provide you with straightforward facts about Medigap plan options, costs, and how to confidently choose a plan that meets your healthcare needs and budget in New York City.


Key Takeaways


Compare 2024 Plans & Rates

Enter Zip Code

Understanding NYC Medicare Supplement Plans


Understanding NYC Medicare Supplement Plans


Medicare Supplement plans, also known as Medigap, are insurance policies designed to complement Original Medicare. These policies provide Medicare supplement coverage for costs not covered by Medicare, such as coinsurance, copayments, and deductibles, offering a robust safety net to beneficiaries in NYC.

With ten different plans available, beneficiaries can choose a plan that best suits their healthcare needs and financial considerations.


Importance of Medigap in NYC

The high cost of healthcare in NYC makes Medigap plans an invaluable asset for residents. They provide a financial cushion against unforeseen medical expenses, helping avoid hefty out-of-pocket costs. Besides financial security, these plans also offer beneficiaries the flexibility to choose their healthcare providers. In a city as diverse and expansive as NYC, this flexibility can be a significant advantage.

Beyond covering out-of-pocket expenses, a Medigap policy also brings peace of mind by offering the same coverage. It allows beneficiaries to focus on their health and wellness without worrying about unpredictable healthcare costs.


Standardized Medigap Plans in NYC

Medigap plans in NYC are standardized by the federal government, ensuring a consistent set of basic benefits across all insurers. This standardization makes it easier for beneficiaries to compare plans and select the one that best meets their healthcare needs and budget.

It should be kept in mind that the available plans have undergone some changes in recent years. For policies sold on or after January 1, 2020, Plans C, F, and high-deductible Plan F are not available to new Medicare beneficiaries. Rest assured, numerous options like Plan G or N, which offer comprehensive benefits, remain available.


Enrollment and Eligibility for NYC Medicare Supplement Plans


Enrollment and Eligibility for NYC Medicare Supplement Plans


Enrolling in a Medigap plan in NYC is fairly straightforward. The primary eligibility requirement is that you must be enrolled in both Medicare Part A and Part B. Additionally, New York State mandates that insurers offer Medigap policies to individuals under 65, such as those with a disability or End-Stage Renal Disease (ESRD), even though federal law does not require it.

The great news is, you can enroll in these plans at any time of the year.


Open Enrollment Period

One of the unique features of Medigap plans in NYC is the continuous Open Enrollment Period. This period begins at age 65 once you’re enrolled in Medicare Part B. The continuous open enrollment means you can choose any plan with any carrier without requiring medical underwriting, offering a great deal of flexibility to beneficiaries.


Guaranteed Issue Rights in New York State

In New York State, Medigap insurers are required to accept applications at any time, without denying based on health status, claims experience, or medical conditions. This is a significant advantage for beneficiaries, as it ensures they can get the coverage they need, irrespective of their health status.

Keep in mind, however, that policies may impose a waiting period of up to six months for pre-existing conditions. This waiting period can be waived or reduced depending on the individual’s previous creditable coverage. So, if you’ve had continuous coverage for the past six months, you can switch to a Medigap plan without worrying about a waiting period for pre-existing conditions, as your Medicare prior coverage will be taken into account.


Popular Medicare Supplement Plans in NYC


Popular Medicare Supplement Plans in NYC


In NYC, Plan G and Plan N are considered the best options for comprehensive Medigap coverage. With Plan G expected to increase in enrollments due to the unavailability of Plans C and F to new Medicare beneficiaries, it’s clear that beneficiaries are seeking comprehensive coverage options that meet their specific healthcare needs.


Plan G: Comprehensive Coverage and Growing Popularity

Medicare Supplement Plan G is becoming a popular choice among beneficiaries in NYC. It offers extensive coverage, including the Part A deductible of $1,632 and the Part B excess charges. This comprehensive coverage appeals to beneficiaries who require frequent medical care and to those who spend time in multiple states.

In addition, Plan G caters to the unique healthcare needs, lifestyle preferences, and budget considerations of beneficiaries. These factors make Plan G one of the most sought-after Medicare Supplement plans for new enrollees in New York City.


Plan N: Lower Premiums with Cost-Sharing

On the other hand, Plan N offers an alternative to Plan G by providing a balance between cost and coverage. It features lower premiums but requires copayments of up to $20 for doctor visits and up to $50 for emergency room visits.

The appeal of Plan N for NYC residents lies in the city’s prohibition of excess charges. Since doctors can’t bill above the Medicare-approved rate, Plan N becomes a viable option for residents seeking cost-effective coverage.


book appointment with

Compare Medicare Plans & Rates in Your Area

Get the latest prices from all the top carriers

Factors Affecting Medicare Supplement Plan Costs in NYC

Factors Affecting Medicare Supplement Plan Costs in NYC


The cost of Medicare Supplement plans in NYC is influenced by several factors such as individual health, age, and area of residence, including the zip code. It’s worth noting that in New York, carriers employ community age rating methods, meaning premiums aren’t determined by individual age. This can be advantageous for older adults who might otherwise face higher premiums.


Average Premiums for Popular Medigap Plans in NYC

So, what can you expect to pay for a Medigap plan in NYC? The average monthly premium for Plan G is approximately $235.40, while Plan N has an average monthly premium of about $213. The monthly premium for Medicare Supplement plans in the city varies widely, ranging from $86 to $390.

Note that there are also several providers that offer plans in NYC. For instance, UnitedHealthcare offers a Plan G option with an average monthly premium of $278.25, while Anthem Inc. provides Plan G and Plan N options, with respective monthly premiums of $289.75 and $205.60. So, it’s worth shopping around and comparing different plans to find one that fits your budget and healthcare needs.


Top NYC Medicare Supplement Insurance Providers


Top NYC Medicare Supplement Insurance Providers


There are several top-notch providers of Medicare Supplement insurance in NYC, including:

  • Humana
  • AARP by UnitedHealthcare
  • Blue Cross Blue Shield
  • Cigna
  • State Farm

These providers have been rated highly by organizations like A.M. Best and J.D. Power for their reliability and customer service.


Comparing Providers and Plans

Comparing your options is crucial when selecting a provider and plan. Resources like can provide personalized assistance to help you weigh different Medicare Supplement plans, guiding you through the enrollment process and helping you find a plan that’s tailored to your specific healthcare needs and preferences.


Alternatives to Medicare Supplement Plans in NYC

Besides Medigap, Medicare beneficiaries in NYC also have the option of Medicare Advantage or Medicare Part C. With 47 different plans from 14 insurers available in the city, Medicare Advantage offers an alternative that may better suit some people’s needs.

Medicare Advantage plans often offer additional benefits such as gym memberships or transportation, as well as coverage for dental and vision services, adding more value beyond Original Medicare. Plus, all Medicare-eligible individuals in NYC have the option of choosing a $0-premium Medicare Advantage plan, offering potential cost savings.


Resources for Medicare Beneficiaries in NYC

Navigating the world of Medicare, Medigap, and Medicaid services can be complex, but fortunately, there are several resources available for beneficiaries in NYC. The New York State Health Insurance Information Counseling and Assistance Program (HIICAP) offers free counseling for Medicare and other health insurance matters. Beneficiaries can also receive one-on-one counseling assistance by contacting the New York State Office for Aging HIICAP.

Another valuable resource is the New York State Department of Financial Services, which provides a portal for Medicare beneficiaries to search for Medicare Supplement insurance carriers and compare their current monthly rates. These resources can provide invaluable assistance as you navigate your Medicare Supplement plan options.



Medicare Supplement plans offer invaluable financial protection for Medicare beneficiaries in NYC. With several plans and providers to choose from, and resources available to help navigate the selection process, you have the tools you need to find a plan that suits your healthcare needs and budget. Whether you choose a comprehensive Plan G, a balanced Plan N, or a cost-effective Medicare Advantage plan, you can rest easy knowing you’re covered.

Compare 2024 Plans & Rates

Enter Zip Code

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the disadvantages of a Medicare Supplement plan?

The disadvantages of a Medicare Supplement plan include high monthly premiums, limited guaranteed enrollment periods, and a lack of additional benefits like vision, dental, or prescription drug coverage. Consider these drawbacks when evaluating your options.


What does an average person pay for Medicare with a supplement?

On average, the cost of Medicare Supplemental health insurance with Plan N premiums is about $100.57 per month for beneficiaries at age 66 and $173.83 per month for beneficiaries at age 85. These costs can vary for individuals based on the coverage chosen and other factors such as income.


What is the purpose of Medicare Supplement plans in NYC?

The purpose of Medicare Supplement plans in NYC is to complement Original Medicare by covering out-of-pocket costs, and offering financial protection to beneficiaries.


How can I enroll in a Medicare Supplement plan in NYC?

To enroll in a Medicare Supplement plan in NYC, you must be enrolled in Medicare Part A and Part B, and you can do so at any time of the year.


Are there alternatives to Medicare Supplement plans in NYC?

Yes, in NYC, Medicare Advantage (or Medicare Part C) offers 47 different plans from 14 insurers as an alternative to Medicare Supplement plans.

Speak to the Professionals about Medigap Plans and Original Medicare

If you find understanding the benefits involved with Original Medicare and Medigap Plans challenging, you’re not alone. Whether it’s a Medigap plan, or you want to know more about the best Medicare Supplement Plans in NYC, we can help. Call our team at 1-888-891-0229 for a free consultation or complete the contact form on this site, and an expert will call you back at a convenient time.

We have decades of experience advising our clients on the complexities of Medicare and Medigap plans, the benefits, cost and deductibles. We’ll ensure you get the best rate in your state and advice you can trust.

Medicare Supplement Plan G Rates